Creativity & work
Is AI Making Your Team’s Ideas Sound the Same?
AI suggestions helped writers produce better-rated stories in one experiment, but the stories also became more alike. Collect your team’s separate ideas before asking a shared assistant to improve them.

Start your next brainstorm by asking each person to bring an idea before consulting an AI assistant. When everyone begins with the same suggestions, the shortlist can fill up with variations on a single idea. A board-game shortlist, for example, can offer different settings while asking players to make the same choices.
How readers and researchers judged the stories
Anil R. Doshi and Oliver P. Hauser analysed 293 eight-sentence stories from an online experiment. Writers were randomly assigned to work on their own or to have the option of asking GPT-4 for one idea or up to five. A separate group rated the stories before being told whether writers had access to AI. Readers gave both groups offered AI ideas higher average ratings for novelty and usefulness. Usefulness included whether the story could be developed into a book.
The researchers used a separate comparison for similarity. They used a numerical representation of each story’s text to compare it with the others in its group. In each group offered AI ideas, stories were closer to the rest of their group on this measure than in the group writing alone. The experiment studied short fiction by UK-based online participants. It gives no estimate of how much variety a design team would gain or lose.
Save each concept before sharing AI suggestions
Give everyone on the team the same board-game brief and ask each person to submit a short concept before seeing anyone else’s or consulting AI. Require a goal and an example of what a player does on a turn. Two proposals with different settings may still be the same game if both ask players to bid for scarce pieces. A proposal that lets players redraw a shared map would offer a different mechanism to test.
Keep the original concepts and group them by how they work. If the team uses AI after that, ask it to find a weakness in each distinct mechanism or propose a rule for testing it. Keep the original and amended versions side by side so the team can see which choices survived the revision.
Before choosing, assess each proposal against the brief and count how many different mechanisms remain. If the shortlist has become variations on one idea, bring back a distinct concept and try it in a quick playtest before discarding it.
Sources and further reading
Sources checked 7 November 2026. Edited and reviewed by AI Boss.