Language and display
BE THE BOSS OF AI.ADRIAN DUNKLEY ↗
← This newspaper edition

A Bigger Bill Does Not Mean a More Urgent Repair

If you use an automated score to rank repair jobs, check what it measures. Past spending can miss a fault that has left people without a working facility.

A bent ochre ruler rests on a tall blue block and hangs above a shorter one.
The Crooked Ruler · Editorial artwork · AI Boss Ltd

Suppose a council uses an automated score to rank building repairs by past spending. It could miss a building whose worst fault has yet to be fixed. A site with a large repainting bill could outrank a building where the only accessible toilet has been out of service for weeks. If the toilet repair is still waiting for parts, there may be little spending to show how long people have gone without it.

A healthcare study shows the danger of measuring the wrong thing

In a 2019 study published in Science, Ziad Obermeyer and colleagues examined a commercial scoring system that helped a US hospital identify insured primary-care patients for extra care management. The system predicted future healthcare spending. At similar scores, the two groups had broadly similar spending in the following year, but Black patients had more active chronic conditions than White patients. At the same count of chronic conditions, spending was lower for Black patients.

The hospital used the 97th percentile of the score as the cutoff for automatically identifying patients for enrolment, roughly the top 3%. To test a different selection rule, the researchers kept the number of places fixed and simulated replacing White patients above the cutoff with Black patients below it who had more chronic conditions. They continued until the patients at the selection cutoff had the same number of conditions. Black patients made up 17.7% of automatic selections. In the simulation the share was 46.5%.

Compare which urgent jobs each repair list leaves out

For a repair test, give facilities staff the same batch of open jobs without showing them the spending-based ranking. Agree what makes a job urgent, such as a safety hazard or loss of the only accessible facility. Ask staff to record the condition report behind each priority and how long people have been affected.

If the crew can take five jobs this week, compare the top five on each list. Record which urgent jobs each list leaves out and why. If spending pushes urgent work below the cutoff, use verified condition and access records to set repair priorities. Keep the spending figures for budgeting.

Sources and further reading

Sources checked 10 November 2026. Edited and reviewed by AI Boss.