2026-11-18 · A CRITICAL THINKING LUNCHEON
The Empty Shelf
Sales fell by half. The AI wants a smaller order. What is the till unable to tell you?

Leah held the supplier’s order form against an empty shelf. Her shop sold lunch boxes. Last week it had sold 40; the week before, 80. She wanted the next delivery to arrive without tying up cash in stock that would sit there.
Her AI assistant read four weekly sales totals and recommended ordering 40 boxes. “Demand has halved,” it wrote. Its screen showed no stock records.
Leah checked the delivery book. The shop had opened last week with 40 boxes and sold the last one on Wednesday. It stayed open through Saturday. A delayed delivery had left three full trading days with none to sell.
“I wrote down nine people who asked on Thursday,” said her assistant, Amir. “Friday and Saturday were too busy. I didn’t keep a count.” Leah could see no duplicate names in his nine entries. Nobody had paid or reserved a box.
The supplier could deliver either 40 or 80 boxes before the shop opened on Monday. Each would cost $US8. Leah could afford either order, but another delivery would take a week. The AI could draft the order; only Leah could send it.
Amir offered to call the nine customers and check the previous weeks’ stock books with her. That would take an hour they had set aside for the window display. The supplier would hold both order sizes until they finished.
Leah put the display cards down. Would she send the AI’s 40-box order now, or use that hour to check what the sales figures had missed?
Compare your decision with the recommendation
Count the days with nothing to sell
Use the held hour to check the stock books and call the nine customers. Ask the AI to separate sales made while boxes were available from days with no stock. Then choose 40 or 80 using the checked records, the cash available and the cost of running out. Leah should approve the order. The clues justify checking; they do not establish the correct order size.
Leah owns the purchase decision and the shop’s cash risk. Amir supplies observations; the AI can compare records and draft an order. It cannot send one.
Read the clues
- The shop sold all 40 boxes it had. Recorded sales could not exceed that supply.
- Three full trading days had no stock. The four sales totals cannot show how many people would have bought a box on those days.
- The nine enquiries show interest, but none is a confirmed sale. Missing Friday and Saturday counts cannot be treated as zero.
- The supplier will hold both quantities. An hour of checking costs display time without removing either purchase option.
| Leah’s action | No observed material impact | Material impact |
|---|---|---|
| Check, then order | After checking, Leah orders 80. Sixty sell; 20 remain. The remaining stock ties up $US160 at purchase cost. No customer is turned away. This is below the exercise’s materiality threshold, but Leah still has to sell the remaining boxes. | The same checks lead to an 80-box order. Only 30 sell. Fifty boxes tie up $US400 at purchase cost. Interest failed to become purchases. The checks improved the basis for approval, but could not guarantee next week’s sales. |
| Send the 40-box order | Leah orders 40 without checking. Thirty-five sell. Five boxes tie up $US40 at purchase cost, and no customer is turned away. A quiet week leaves the unsupported demand claim untested. | All 40 sell. Staff then record 15 distinct customers who are ready to buy but leave without a box. The shop misses those purchases. Their revenue and profit cannot be calculated because the story gives no selling price. Leah must track the shortage while waiting for delivery. |
Scenario assumptions: quantities, prices and outcomes belong to this exercise. Assess one trading week. Material impact means at least $US320 tied up in unsold boxes at purchase cost, or at least 10 distinct customers ready to buy who leave because none are available. These are possible outcomes, with no assigned probabilities. A quiet week does not establish that the decision was sound.
What the till leaves out
Forty sales show 40 completed purchases. They place a lower bound on last week’s demand. With three days of empty shelves, they cannot establish a 50% fall in demand. Nor can nine enquiries be added as nine certain sales. The number of customers who would have paid remains unknown.
An 80-box order costs $US640; 40 boxes cost $US320. The extra cash commitment is $US320. Unsold stock at purchase cost is not automatically a loss: it may sell later. Future selling price, storage costs and later demand would be needed to estimate profit or loss.
Apply the four Ds
- Delegation
- Have AI organise sales and stock records. Leah decides how much cash the shop will commit.
- Description
- Supply opening stock, delivery dates and out-of-stock periods. Ask for separate counts of purchases, enquiries and unknown demand.
- Discernment
- Check the claim that demand halved against the empty-shelf days. Treat the nine enquiries as interest until the customers confirm what they want.
- Diligence
- Keep purchase approval with Leah. Record daily stock availability and unmet purchase requests, then review the order after the next delivery cycle.
4Ds: Rick Dakan, Joseph Feller and Anthropic. Framework and attribution.
Put a check before the next order
For this exercise, S4 means: specify which records the assistant needs; stress-test its recommendation against days with no stock; safeguard purchasing by keeping send permission with Leah; scrutinise the next week’s stock and missed purchases. S4 is Adrian Dunkley’s proposed teaching approach.
At the next stock review, put a column for “hours with none available” beside the sales total. Ask the buyer to explain any proposed reduction before sending the order.
