Language and display
BE THE BOSS OF AI.ADRIAN DUNKLEY ↗
← Daily critical thinking

2026-11-19 · A CRITICAL THINKING LUNCHEON

The Road That Was Open

A food hub has 60 meal boxes to deliver. The AI puts both vans on a route through the same bridge.

A folded-paper delivery van near a barricaded bridge over a pale-blue river.
A paper van approaches a bridge barricade.

Marcia pushed the last crate against the van door. Sixty meal boxes had to reach two community kitchens by noon. Each kitchen expected thirty, and each van could carry exactly that many. Outside, rainwater still dripped from the depot roof.

At 11:10, the route planner put both vans on a route through Cedar Bridge. It gave a travel time of 25 minutes to each kitchen. Both drivers had come in early to make the first delivery after the storm.

Marcia almost printed the routes. Then she saw a pencil note beside the bridge on the depot map: ‘Barricades up, 7:40.’ The overnight road file the planner had used ended at 6 a.m.

‘The note could be old,’ said Imani, who drove the first van. ‘I can call the road desk. They said to give them ten minutes.’ She traced the other route with her finger. The depot’s manual estimate was 35 minutes to either kitchen via Hill Road, which the road desk had already confirmed was open.

The planner could draft routes from a new closure list, but it could neither obtain official confirmation nor send a driver out. Marcia had the keys. If she waited for the road desk, the detour would get both vans there at 11:55 if the estimate held, with five minutes to spare.

Imani held out her hand for the keys. Marcia looked from the route printout to the pencil note.

Compare your decision with the recommendation

Check the road before handing over the keys

Send both vans down Hill Road at 11:10. The road desk has confirmed it is open, and the 35-minute estimate leaves 15 minutes before noon. Ask the desk to check Cedar Bridge for the next run. If the only choices were to wait or use the AI’s route now, wait until 11:20 and take Hill Road if the desk cannot confirm the bridge is open. Marcia approves the route.

Marcia controls dispatch. The road desk supplies access information, and the AI can redraw a route from that information.

Read the clues

  • The planner used a file that ended at 6 a.m. The pencil note reports barricades at 7:40, so the file could not contain that report.
  • The pencil note is reason to check. It cannot establish whether the bridge is still closed at 11:10.
  • Both vans share the bridge, so a closure can delay both loads together.
  • The confirmed Hill Road route takes 35 minutes on the estimate. Waiting ten minutes leaves only five minutes for an unexpected delay.
Four possible outcomes by the depot’s noon handover deadline
Marcia’s decisionNo observed material impactMaterial impact
Wait for confirmation

The desk confirms the bridge is closed. Both vans take Hill Road at 11:20 and arrive at 11:55.

Both kitchens receive their 30 boxes. The route still had only five minutes of slack.

The vans leave on Hill Road at 11:20. A fallen branch adds ten minutes to both journeys.

Both loads arrive at 12:05. Five minutes of slack could not absorb the extra ten.

Release both vans now

Cedar Bridge has reopened. The 11:10 departure gets both vans in at 11:35.

All 60 boxes arrive early. Marcia still released both vans without knowing the bridge’s status.

The bridge is still closed. Reaching the barricades, turning back and joining Hill Road costs 20 minutes before the 35-minute detour.

Both loads arrive at 12:05. The kitchens have to change their noon handover plans.

These times and outcomes are teaching assumptions. Material impact means any load reaching its kitchen after noon. The table compares the two choices Marcia was considering. It leaves out the third option: taking Hill Road immediately. No case supplies a probability.

Apply the four Ds

Delegation
Ask AI to draft a route. Keep dispatch with Marcia.
Description
Give the planner dated closures, permitted roads and the noon deadline.
Discernment
Compare the file time with the barricade report. Ask the road desk to settle what the two records cannot.
Diligence
Log the source and time of the check. Tell both kitchens if either arrival time slips.

4Ds: Rick Dakan, Joseph Feller and Anthropic. Framework and attribution.

Check one route you depend on

Find the time on the source a planner used. Name who can confirm any change since that time, then decide when to switch to the fallback.