The pitch says the product is ready. What proves it?
Use Gemini Notebook to check a hotel vendor’s claims against its evidence and decide what to request before you approve a trial.
By Adrian Dunkley & the AI Boss team
Tool details and news reflect the 15 November 2026 edition.
Mark what the hotel vendor has not proved
In this practice exercise, a vendor says its hotel booking assistant is ready for customer trials. You will check three claims against the vendor’s evidence note.
Use Gemini Notebook to separate what the source proves from what the pitch promises. Give the completed check to the person deciding whether to fund a trial.
Delegation · Description · Discernment · Diligence. Test every claim against a source. Next lesson: record the evidence that would change the decision. Framework by Rick Dakan and Joseph Feller, developed with Anthropic.
Check the vendor’s claims in Gemini Notebook
- Open Gemini Notebook in a browser and sign in if asked. Select Create new notebook, then Add sources and Copied text. Copy only the Practice source block below, paste it as the source and name it Practice vendor pitch.
- On this newsletter, select Copy prompt. Return to Gemini Notebook, open Chat, paste and send the prompt. Compare the answer with the expected result.
Google lists copied text as a supported source and lists Jamaica among supported countries. A Workspace administrator may need to enable access.
Practice source
Pitch: “We have three signed resort pilots. Our booking assistant is ready for customer trials and cuts booking errors by 20%.”
Evidence note: “The prototype was tested on a public hotel FAQ. One hotel requested a demo. No pilot agreement has been signed. No change in booking errors has been measured.”
Input
Select the source named “Practice vendor pitch” if it is not already selected. Use only that source. It contains a Pitch and an Evidence note.
Instructions
Make a table with four columns: Claim; Exact evidence-note passage; Status; Missing proof. Use Supported when the evidence establishes the whole claim, Partly supported when it establishes only part, and Unsupported when it establishes none or directly contradicts the claim. A demo request or public FAQ test does not establish readiness for a customer trial. Quote the closest passage from the Evidence note, including a passage that contradicts the claim. If that note has no relevant passage, write [CHECK] in that column. Write [CHECK] beside every missing fact or document. End with one sentence telling a hotel owner whether to approve a trial, request evidence or stop.
| Claim | Exact evidence-note passage | Status | Missing proof |
|---|---|---|---|
| Three signed pilots | “No pilot agreement has been signed.” | Unsupported | Signed agreements [CHECK] |
| Ready for customer trials | “The prototype was tested on a public hotel FAQ.” | Unsupported | Hotel test plan, agreed target and reviewer [CHECK] |
| 20% fewer booking errors | “No change in booking errors has been measured.” | Unsupported | Baseline, test records and measured result [CHECK] |
Expected recommendation: Ask the vendor for a hotel test plan with a baseline, agreed target and named reviewer before approving a trial.
- Save the sourceKeep a copy of the source and add the date you checked it.
- Assign each gapName who will obtain the missing document or test result.
- Record the choiceThe approver records trial, request evidence or stop, with the result that would let the trial go ahead.
Measure one customer task before you buy the automation
Reddit pick. In an r/smallbusiness discussion, u/Bholenaught questioned the return-on-investment figures people post online. The post records one person’s concern. For a hotel booking assistant, record errors per 100 bookings and staff checking minutes per booking, then use the same measures during a limited trial.
AI news
Barbadian grid startup wins the Future Caribbean Buildathon
Winners were announced on 12 November. The St Kitts Nevis Observer published a CMC report on 15 November that Andrew Narine’s Caribbean Grid AI took first place. The venture is developing renewable-energy forecasts for power storage and distribution. Narine told CMC the team had done forecasting assessments after utility requests and was seeking a pilot with Barbados Light & Power.
Our takeaway. A competition result does not establish utility performance. Ask for the pilot question, baseline, pass condition and named utility reviewer before treating the pitch as evidence of utility results.
ChatGPT Wallet starts a limited US rollout
On 13 November, OpenAI began rolling out ChatGPT Wallet in dots, ChatGPT’s personal assistants. Eligibility starts with US Pro subscribers aged 18 or older who have an eligible US-issued card and US billing address. The user reviews the merchant, items, total and card before biometric approval.
Our takeaway. OpenAI limits this rollout to eligible US users. For any purchasing agent test, require a person to confirm those four fields and check the merchant’s order confirmation. Approval alone does not prove the order was placed.
Sponsored · Our training
AI Officer board-level training
StarApple AI’s executive AI Officer programme helps leaders examine AI investment, oversight, accountability and measured value. Bring one vendor proposal. Define the evidence the board needs, the executive who owns the result and the point at which the organisation should pause.
AI Boss Show & Tell: check a proposal against stated priorities
On 15 October, Adrian said he built a Board Meter to review documents against specific stakeholders’ priorities. Use the Stakeholder Meter approach: list priorities stakeholders have stated, cite the proposal passage for each one, flag gaps or assumptions, then propose an edit. The labels express editorial judgements. They cannot predict whether someone will approve the proposal. Confirm priorities with the people concerned. Ask about the approach.
Check one vendor before you sign
Open the AI Vendor Assessment and answer about one supplier using records you have seen. The live tool asks 14 questions across positioning, language, technical substance, team and commercial protection. It returns a score, a five-area breakdown and follow-up points. You can view the result without sharing contact details.
Hypothetical use case. A hotel is considering an AI booking assistant. The operations lead uses public product claims, non-sensitive test findings, team details and the contract terms they can disclose. If the result flags weak commercial protection, the owner asks the organisation’s lawyer to review remedies and exit terms before signing.
The score is based on the answers you submit. The tool applies fixed rules to your answers. It cannot audit the supplier, determine compliance or predict whether the vendor will succeed. Do not enter confidential customer or contract details.
Further reading from the Caribbean AI Association
- How to test an AI service for local use explains why teams should test actions, evidence use and approval limits with local cases.
- How Caribbean banks can use draft AI governance guidance distinguishes proposed voluntary guidance from legal requirements and covers board oversight and vendor checks.
- AI readiness in the Caribbean examines infrastructure, data, talent, governance and adoption.
Pick one promise in a proposal. What document would prove it?
Be the boss of AI
