Two reports agree. Did one copy the other?
Use Gemini Notebook and a Bridgetown vendor case to trace copied claims before you approve an AI pilot.
By Adrian Dunkley & the AI Boss team
Check whether the memo repeats the vendor’s claim
Open Gemini Notebook in a browser and create a notebook. Select Add sources, then Copied text. Paste the vendor paragraph below and name it Source A. Add the consultant paragraph as Source B. Select both sources. Google’s current help page confirms these controls. Access depends on your account, country, age and workplace administrator.
Practice source A: vendor proposal
Island Service AI proposes a customer-support pilot for Bridgetown Credit Union. The proposal claims 95% answer accuracy and says staff will approve every customer response before it is sent. It gives no test method, sample size, local-language results, privacy review or exception process.
Practice source B: consultant memo
The consultant recommends a pilot because “the system achieved 95% answer accuracy.” The memo cites the vendor proposal. It adds no separate test, customer record, staff interview or source.
Select Copy prompt. Paste the instructions into the notebook’s Chat box and send them.
Instructions
Use only Source A and Source B. Trace the 95% accuracy claim and the staff-approval promise to the source that first states each. Produce a table with the columns Claim, Where it appears, Earliest supplied source and Independent evidence. For each claim, state which supplied document first states it and which repeats it. Mark absent evidence [MISSING]. Do not treat repetition as confirmation.
Recommend HOLD (do not start), REVISE (change the proposal) or TEST (run a controlled pilot). Give the operations manager one next action, one pass condition and one stop rule. Keep staff approval before any response is sent. End with the exact files or facts still needed. Do not invent them.
| Claim | Where it appears | Earliest source | Independent evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 95% answer accuracy | Source A and Source B | Source A, vendor proposal | [MISSING] |
- Request the test recordGet the cases, method and errors behind the figure.
- Check the recordsTest sample local enquiries and record every wrong answer.
- Control the trialHold deployment until every response shows staff approval.
| Decision point | Evidence to request | Suggested owner |
|---|---|---|
| Answer accuracy | Local test set, method and errors | Operations manager |
| Customer data | Where customer information goes and who reviewed it | Privacy lead |
| Staff control | Test log showing approval before sending | Service supervisor |
Check that Gemini Notebook identifies the copied 95% claim, marks the missing evidence and keeps staff approval in the workflow.
Delegation · Description · Discernment · Diligence. Record where each claim started and who checked it. Next lesson: rerun the check when a source changes. AI Fluency by Rick Dakan and Joseph Feller, developed with Anthropic.
Ask for the test record behind the output
Reddit pick. In an 18 November r/GeminiAI post, a creator said Gemini 4 Neon built a 3D city, checked it in a browser and fixed defects. Treat the post as one builder’s account. Before accepting a draft at work, ask for the source list, the checks completed and any defect still open.
AI news
Eight Jamaican teams reach a New York Stock Exchange final
At a 13 November showcase, Jamaican teams presented projects for small-business credit, clinic triage and building-work verification. A Future Caribbean release dated 17 November describes the projects; it is not an independent product test.
Our takeaway. For a pilot contract, ask a team to demonstrate one customer task with a sample record. Record what works and any remaining defects. Use mentorship to address the gaps.
Google releases Gemini 4 Neon across paid products
Google announced Gemini 4 Neon on 18 November. Access is rolling out in the AI Studio paid tier, business products, Antigravity for Pro and Ultra users, and the Gemini app for Pro and Ultra users.
Artificial Analysis scored the model 61 at its highest reasoning setting. The score combines nine coding, research and reasoning tests. Check how Neon handles the supplied vendor case before using it in your approval process.
Our takeaway. Give Neon and your usual model the practice sources above. Keep your usual model unless Neon traces the copied claim and preserves the approval rule more reliably on your examples.
AI Boss Show & Tell
On 19 November, we prepared The Last Clear Signal, a six-page critical-thinking exercise and 4D Decision Canvas. This practice story asks staff to trace two green checks back to their shared, outdated drill report before drafting an emergency update. Ask about adapting the exercise.
Check the evidence behind a vendor’s pitch
The AI Vendor Assessment helps an executive, buyer or project owner review one vendor’s claims, team, technical evidence and contract terms. Use records you have checked to answer the questions.
On 19 November, we tested it with sample answers: a named delivery team, a structured pilot, documented data terms and a written exit path. The tool scored that profile 98 out of 100 and returned Credible Partner, with a dimension breakdown and one-page report. Contact details were optional.
The score reflects the answers entered. Ask the vendor for evidence behind each answer before using the report to plan a small trial. In this sample profile, the immediate check is whether the vendor can prove its named projects and builders. The score is a rule-based self-assessment, not certification, regulatory approval or a performance forecast.
Sponsored · Our training
AI Officer board-level training
StarApple AI’s executive AI Officer programme covers strategy, governance, risk and a guided build. The board-level application uses the same programme to assess investment, oversight, accountability and measured value.
Further reading from the Caribbean AI Association
- Banking AI guidelines consultation draft asks teams to record the use case, owner, model, tests, limits and approval. It is an independent consultation draft.
- Caribbean AI needs a local test explains how to test one service with local sources and practice records before customer data.
- S4 for Caribbean AI safety shows how teams can check local sources, language and responsibility.
Which repeated claim in your next report needs an original source?
Adrian Dunkley & the AI Boss team
Be the boss of AI
